Paul Oberjuerge header image 2

Donovan to Stay in England? Thinking It Through

January 18th, 2010 · 5 Comments · Abu Dhabi, Landon Donovan, soccer, World Cup

I knew this was coming.

I knew it while standing in the newsroom here in Abu Dhabi two nights ago, stopping on my way out out of the building and watching via computer the final minutes of the Premier League match between Everton and Manchester City.

Everton coach David Moyes substituted for Landon Donovan in the 90th minute of the match … and Landon got a huge ovation from the Everton home crowd of 37,378. The same crowd that had chanted “USA” every time Donovan stood over a dead ball.

And it made me wonder …

1. In his club career (as opposed to international career) Has Landon Donovan ever had that many people cheer for him — just him — at once?

2. Will he find the intensity of the whole English soccer experience intoxicating?

3. Will he attempt to extend his stay in England?

Let’s see if we can figure out some answers, though we will give you one right off: Landon at least is thinking about extending his stay, according to the Liverpool Echo newspaper.

To recap: Landon is spending 10 weeks at Everton on a loan from the Los Angeles Galaxy of Major League Soccer.

The way this was set up, Landon is scheduled to be back in Los Angeles by the middle of March. While the Premier League season continues on.

The Galaxy/MLS hold the rights to his services.

So,  for Landon to stay on through the end of the European season (as David Beckham will, in Milan), he will have to come to some sort of accommodation with the MLS/Galaxy.

Would he want to make that happen?

If he is on the receiving end of many more outburts of adulation of the sort he got Saturday night, when Everton rolled over Manchester City, 2-0, he might.

So far, it’s been one big lovefest, which I’m not sure any of us saw coming. Including Landon.

Looking back, we can see that his arrival was heralded around the club as a sort of “cavalry to the rescue” thing. Several of Everton’s attacking players were hurt or off in Africa or out of form, and management told fans during the holiday break that it was going to plug the hole by bringing in America’s best player.

Then, in his first few minutes with the club, he swung in a nice corner kick that Everton turned into a goal, and it’s been off to the races, since. Everton tied that match, on the road at Arsenal (the team that thrashed Everton 6-1 back on the opening weekend), and then Everton came back to handle Man City at home, and that’s four points and zero defeats since The Yank arrived on the right wing.

Landon says he is surprised by the intensity of his welcome. And how amazing must it be given his long career in MLS, with its small, often limp crowds?

But can he make a lengthier stay happen?

Historically, Landon Donovan pretty much has gotten what he wants. Whether that’s going or staying. He wanted out of Germany? He got out. Twice. He wanted to play in Los Angeles? It happened. He wanted loans to Bayern Munich and Everton, and got them. He asked for an extention in Los Angeles. He got one.

To stay with Everton through May would, however, be his biggest trick yet. It would require:

1. Everton wanting to keep him and making it worth his while. Everton is not a rich club and it plays in one of the smallest stadiums in the Premiership. Donovan might be willing to stick around for the sake of improving his “brand” recognition, but cash … could be an issue.

2. Will the Galaxy/MLS let him go? Historically, the league has let anyone go if they got what they felt was a fair transfer fee, in return. But would the league allow one of its 2-3 marquee players disappear for months … or maybe years … when he’s signed through 2013? He may be the one exception to the “we’ll let him go for any reasonable offer” rule. The Galaxy/MLS could play hardball here, and that would severely muck up things.

3. Will the Galaxy/MLS let him extend his stay through the end of the season? This could happen. It would allow Landon to play another 8-10 matches, at a very high level, in the run-up to the World Cup; it would allow Everton to pay him as a part-timer; and it would give MLS and the Galaxy some certainty about his returning, in late July or early August, after the World Cup.

Then there’s this: Everton has four just huge matches in February — at Liverpool, home against Chelsea, home against Manchester United, at Tottenham. What living soccer standout wouldn’t want to be part of those? And will the experience of it make him want more?

Anyway, lots of balls in play, now. England, the Premiership, adoring fans, a contract with MLS, a less-than-wealthy Everton club, forfeiting that big MLS salary, the World Cup, Landon’s preference for being “home” in SoCal.

Let’s keep an eye on what happens over the next 4-6 weeks. If Everton still loves Landon and he still loves Everton … something could get done.

Tags:

5 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Ian // Jan 18, 2010 at 3:27 PM

    The interesting variable in all of this is the possible work stoppage in the MLS. It sounds as if the negotiations are not going well at all. It would be horrible if MLS made him come back against his will AND they weren’t playing.

    As you know, I was never a big fan, but he’s won me over. He hasn’t been perfect with Everton, but he’s provided support on the wing to allow Pienaar to move into the center so Fellaini can run roughshod over people. That foursome (with the Russian or Leon Osman on the left) was controlling the midfield against two much more talented sides.

    Donovan isn’t being relied upon to score. He’s being asked to pressure and create. Those are his best qualities to me. I said from the beginning that Moyes would be a good coach for him. Assuming he stays healthy, I think it could be the best thing for him to stay until the World Cup, then bring that confidence to South Africa.

  • 2 Doug // Jan 18, 2010 at 3:51 PM

    Have people been watching the same games I have? I think there was only a few touches for Donovan in the Man City game when he didn’t turn it over. He seemed unable or too nervous to play the quick passing game with the rest of the Everton midfield, and the few times he tried to run at defenders they took it from him. He had that one nice sequence where he took it on the side and drifted in along the top of the box, but his shot was easily deflected. That was it, except for the corner kicks, but all those guys can bend a corner. Are the English just being nice or do they really like him? I’m not seeing it.

  • 3 Ryan // Jan 18, 2010 at 6:31 PM

    Some have reported that Landon’s new contract has a clause in it that if Landon wants to leave and a club offers a pre-determined price for him (some have said it’s 7 million pounds) that MLS must accept it and let him leave. If that is true, it makes things much easier on Landon, but even though that isn’t much money, relatively, Everton was said to have no money at all to spend on transfers until the summer.

  • 4 Ian // Jan 19, 2010 at 1:00 PM

    Wow. I can’t believe I’m saying this, Doug, but I think you’re being too hard on him. His first touch has been good most of the time. No worse than most players.

    He’s not a star in england. but he’s good. and he’s causing problems for the opposition. That’s a success.

  • 5 Charles // Jan 19, 2010 at 1:26 PM

    I agree with Ian, regarding the significantly growing chance of an MLS work stoppage and its potential impact on Donovan’s loan at Everton.

    I think Landon is intelligent to hedge his bets. It seems there might not be an MLS around to play in if management pushes too far in the MLS CBA “negotiations”.

    I can’t imagine MLS being able to survive a strike or lockout, so unless no news is good news….Landon may find himself permanently at Goodison Park.

Leave a Comment