This is the rumor bouncing around the internet: Landon Donovan will go to French club Paris St-Germain, based here in the capital of France.
The rumor originated from something called 10sport, a French site that a few days ago reported that PSG is in negotiations with Donovan (or, presumably, his agent, Richard Motzkin) to secure the Los Angeles Galaxy forward’s services — either for three months or so during the Major League Soccer offseason, or as a straight transfer.
So, I thought I would ask Landon myself. “Any truth to the rumor,” I asked him, via e-mail.
Landon replied last night.
“No comment,” he said.
I’m trying to remember what “no comment” means when Landon uses it. (And he rarely uses it.) I think it tends to mean “you’re onto something but I can’t say anything about it.”
I believe he no-commented me in 2005, just before the March qualifying match at Mexico City, when the rumor of his joining the Galaxy and MLS on a transfer from Bayer Leverkusen was going around hot and heavy.
As you may recall, Donovan was transferred from Leverkusen to the Galaxy within, like, a week. So …
I believe this has more of a chance of happening than the Livorno/Serie A rumor that was going around back in July.
From Donovan’s perspective, PSG has to be far more attractive.
Livorno is in a more prestigious league than is PSG; France’s Ligue 1 is (at best) the fifth-best league in Europe, significantly behind the leagues in England, Spain, Italy and Germany, and arguably behind Turkey, too.
But Livorno figures to struggle in Serie A, while PSG is a contender in France.
And then there is the matter of location, location, location.
Livorno (still sometimes known as Leghorn, in English) is a semi-dreary port city on the Tyrrhenian Sea. It’s in Tuscany, but it’s not in the heart of Tuscany like, say, Florence or Siena.
Paris … is, well, Paris, and in his very brief e-mail Landon described it as an “amazing city.” No one would argue that. The idea of getting paid to live and work here … well, that’s mighty attractive.
There may not be such a thing as a “Donovan brand” yet, certainly not like “Brand Beckham” that the Galaxy bought into two years ago. But exposure in the City of Light couldn’t hurt Donovan. At all.
He speaks German and what he calls “soccer Spanish” … but I don’t think he speaks any French, and the PSG team is made up mostly of French nationals, even if many of them are of recent African origin. The coach, Antoine Kambouare, is from New Caledonia, a French possession in the South Pacific.
But soccer is soccer, and language isn’t a major impediment, on the field.
PSG is an interesting club, with a lot of history, and not all of it good. It has a reputation for attracting race-baiting fans who like to fight. It may have one of the rougher fan bases in France, actually. But the club appears to be on an upswing (it’s 2-0-1 after three matches), and Donovan could be part of that.
The club’s best-known players are Claude Makelele, a French international, defensive midfielder and the captain; and 5-foot-5 winger Ludovic Giuly.
In its first three matches, PSG has used nearly the same lineup throughout, starting 10 players in all three matches.
Where would Landon fit in here? Because, unlike, say, Bayern Munich, where Landon spent the winter earlier this year, he probably would come here expecting to play, providing he is healthy and in form, of course. After all, this is a lower-level league than Germany’s and Landon, at 27, is in his prime and is, arguably, the best field player ever to come out of the U.S.
So, if he plays here, it would have to be at the expense of someone at midfield or at forward.
PSG’s forwards, so far, have been Mevlut Erding, a 22-year-old Turk who just joined the club and has two goals, and Peguy Luyindula, a 30-year-old native of Congo who has one goal. And the other midfield regulars, at the moment, are Stephane Sessegnon, a playmaker from Benin, and Jeremy Clement, a French native who tends to play on the left side and is known more for his defense than scoring.
Just looking at age and form, the guess would be that Donovan might contest for playing time with Luyindula, who has 13 goals in 70 appearances for PSG, which isn’t bad, but isn’t tearing up the league, either. Or, if Donovan is used as a winger, as he has been with the national team, of late, maybe he pushes Clement, a smallish speed guy, as Donovan is.
Anyway, I wonder how anyone can pay attention to the game while living in Paris. That has to be a test for every player in the team. But maybe it wouldn’t be any more of a distraction than is playing with David Beckham.
The other thought I shared with Landon is the sense that Paris doesn’t seem particularly in love with PSG. (Actually, Paris seems too grand and cosmopolitan for anything as common and grubby as professional sports; this may be the least sports-conscious city on the planet.)
PSG seems to have a fairly muted local presence. I haven’t checked lately, but a few years ago the club had a merchandise store on the Champs Elysees, but other than that … I haven’t seen, while out and around here for three weeks, any advertising or promotional material trying to sell the team or its stadium, Parc des Princes, which sits in a working-class neighborhood in the southwest corner of the city.
The club drew an estimated 30,000 for its home opener, against LeMans, which is well short of a sellout. So …
Another aspect of this, a complicating factor, is whether Donovan goes to Paris on a loan or on a straight transfer. He told me, after coming back from Bayern in March, that he thought he would be returning to Europe, and seemed to prefer the idea of a straight transfer (a full-time switch, that is) … but he was concerned that MLS would not let him go. He is almost finished with the fifth year of his five-year contract with the Galaxy/MLS, but … the club/league hold two seasons’ worth of options. Effectively controlling his movements through late 2011, that is.
To date, the impression created is that MLS feels as if it needs the best-known American player … and has set an unrealistically high transfer fee for him. (Someone who knows the situation well said they “can’t imagine” MLS letting Landon go for anything short of a huge chunk of money). And failing an outright transfer, it’s difficult for a player (any player) to make an impact on a three-month loan.
So, yes, lots of ducks that have to be lined up in a row for this to work out.
Anyway, this is a fun rumor. I believe Ligue 1 is a better fit than Italy (and certainly better than Germany) for a player of Donovan’s size, style and panache. And even if things go badly … at the end of the day (or the end of the night) you’re still in Paris.
We’ll see how this turns out. And I may go take a look at PSG next Saturday, when they play at home against Lille. See what Landon might be in for.
9 responses so far ↓
1 Kartik // Aug 23, 2009 at 5:15 PM
Thanks for actually trying to do some reporting unlike other sources, but PSG are NOT title contenders, and Turkey only has 1 or 2 good teams. You’re right in saying speed does seem to kill in Ligue 1 as Charlie Davies has demonstrated, and it’s also good that he has a chance to be a major player for a such a big team (in terms of their history and fan base). He might be missing a lot of Champions league action though…
2 Grosso // Aug 23, 2009 at 8:08 PM
I do not suppose you have any idea about what you are talking in regards of the Ligue 1 or PSG. I noted a few inaccuracies, as well as some comments that reveal a blatant lack of knowledge about them.
3 MatthewPSG // Aug 23, 2009 at 8:59 PM
Landon donovan needs PSG ALLEZ PARIS ALLEZ PSG
PARIS CEST MAGIK
4 Claude05 // Aug 25, 2009 at 3:43 PM
Kartik, who exactly are you referring to when you say “Thanks for actually trying to do some reporting unlike other sources”?
5 George H // Aug 25, 2009 at 5:48 PM
Interesting piece. Having attended the PSG-Toulouse match last fall, I can tell you that the supporters are very passionate about PSG. I think that the relegation scare in 2007 made their fans appreciate top-flight football.
The problem with Paris and most other cities in Ligue 1 is that it only has one club. It’s not like other major European leagues where there are two or more clubs in each city. Sure, there are derbies against other Ligue 1 clubs, but it’s definitely not the same as an inter-city rival.
All that said, this would be a good fit for Donovan. I hope that it happens because he needs a new challenge on the club level and looks ready to grab it with both hands.
Let’s just hope that MLS HQ doesn’t get too greedy.
6 A guy // Aug 26, 2009 at 3:43 PM
Kartik runs majorleaguesoccer.com. Just for full disclosure.
7 Laurent_Paris // Aug 27, 2009 at 1:13 AM
If Donovan comes to PSG, he must to know that there is a lot of good forwards in the club (Hoarau, Erding, Kezman, Luyindula) and offensive miedfields (Giuly, Sessegnon, Rothen), so it will be difficult to him to be in the 11 players who start the game.
French championship is good, is the fourth-best league in Europe (after England, Spain, Italy, equal with Germany. Behind Turkey ? Is it a joke ?), fourth because the best French players play in England and Spain.
PSG is the 2nd most popular club in France, in spite of sportive difficults since some years. Audience 40,000 for every game in Parc des Princes, most beautiful stadium in France.
An important thing : the owner of PSG, Colony Capital, is an… American firm ! It could be a very good marketing bargain for Colony Capital to have an American player in PSG team.
8 guy // Sep 5, 2009 at 1:33 PM
Any club named after Saint Germain-de-Pres can’t be all bad. Giuly and Makalele were pretty good in their day too. Also, always thought Ligue Un under-rated. How can it be viewed 5th-best or worse when the l’Equipe de France appear in two of the last three Coupe du Monde finals.
9 51NC3P0NG // Nov 25, 2009 at 9:16 AM
The day after the MLS Cup Final there were web posts unofficially linking Landon Donovan with four clubs. The clubs were Livorno, Paris St. Germain, Glasgow Celtic, and (most wildly on some English talk-radio show) Liverpool.
Assuming all these clubs have actual interest, and that’s a big if, I find it difficult to believe that any of them would be a good fit for Donovan.
There is a small but growing contingent of American footballers who are stuck in a sort of limbo. Their wage and transfer fee valuations are too great for the budget of clubs where they would be likely to start in the first team, and their reputation isn’t considered to have a fine enough football pedigree at the bigger clubs that can afford to spend that kind of money. Thus the usual story of an American going to a high-profile club is that regardless of how well they might be training and playing, they inevitably end up buried deep in the squad in favor of European/African/South American players who are considered known quantities playing at that “level”. There have been exceptions to this, but not many.
So, assuming that the rumors have any shred of truth to them you would have to assume that: Liverpool would be an awful choice. It would be like Leverkusen all over again for Donovan. Regardless of how well he played or trained, I doubt he’d be given a second glance at Anfield. It would be a classic case of what I call a “Glass Display Case” transfer. Meaning that the club purchasing the player has only done so to collect a name player as cover for whoever else is currently favored in the team at that position. Although PSG might be the best option, it seems like more of a lateral move. Donovan moves to a “better neighborhood” but the question is would he be given more than two matches to show he belongs? Certainly Leverkusen failed to afford him that opportunity. Scottish football is hard on the bones, and sometimes they play in what could be described as rainy slop, but Parkhead might be the best destination of the four for Donovan. Livorno would be the same sort of Glass Case deal that Onyewu was dealing with at the San Siro – or is it the Guiseppe Meazza?, they never seem able to make up their minds in Milan.
I think the best case scenario for Donovan would be a second tier European or British club that has a better than average shot at promotion to the top. It would be fun if this sort of opportunity leads him back to Germany, as I imagine he would be highly motivated to kick the spaghetti out of Leverkusen and Bayern Munich at every possible opportunity. What better thing could you hope for than the chance to make the people that doubted your ability look like idiots?
Leave a Comment